If you’ve spent more than five minutes in a Leica forum, (jokingly) you will see that lenses under the name Dr. Walter Mandler carry the same weight as a holy relic. Mandler was the wizard at Leitz Canada who seems to have prioritized “character” and “draw” in his optical designs.
For decades, his design of the Summicron 35mm ƒ/2 v4 was affectionately dubbed the “King of Bokeh” (KOB) for many photographers.
Leica has always been a higher tier in the photo world, with original v4 prices currently hovering in the $2,500–$3,500 range, resulting in many folks looking through the window. Enter the Mandler 35mm ƒ/2, a modern recreation that aims to put that legendary 7-element soul into a package that doesn’t require a deep bank account.
Mandler Build Characteristic: Brass vs Aluminium
The first thing you notice about the Mandler 35mm is how unapologetically “classic” it feels. It comes in two distinct flavors right now (more versions in future updates):
The Black and Silver Version: Made of aluminum, it’s feather-light (around 139g). It feels like it’s barely there on an M body, making it a perfect EDC (everyday carry) lens.
The Platinum Silver Version: This one is brass-based and significantly heftier. This is like the Typ11311 that costs around $6500. If you like your gear to feel like a precision instrument that could double as a pretty jewel, this is the one.
The Rendering: That “Leica Glow”
The Mandler isn’t trying to beat the $9,000 APO-Summicron at its own game. It’s playing a different sport entirely.
Center Sharpness: Surprisingly excellent. Even wide open at ƒ/2, the center holds up beautifully on high-resolution sensors. If you keep your subject in the middle third, you’ll get plenty of detail.
Mid Edges: Here is where the “Mandler Magic” of this version of the lens features (or “flaws,” depending on your perspective) happens. There is a noticeable fall-off in sharpness.
Far Edges: Sharpness drops significantly in the mid corner and stays soft at most apertures but also suffers from extreme sharper edges becoming sharper than the mid tier. Heavy field curvature but let me give you much more details about this characteristic. As most lenses, there is also light vignetting that add charm to the photos.
The Bokeh: This is why you buy this lens. The out-of-focus areas are certainly unique to the vintage lenses. I have to say that modern ASPH lenses have a smooth blur but often make your subject look like a cut-out-paste into a blurred background that some say is sterile while the Mandler transitions from focus to blur with a gentle vintage gradient. At ƒ/2, you get a hint of that “swirly” bokeh that makes portraits pop in a retrospective form.
Sharp and glowy
Note: Just like the original v4, this lens “glows.” When shooting against harsh light or with bright highlights, you’ll see a soft bloom. It’s not a defect; it’s the aesthetic. If your original KOB has a bit of haze, you will see more blooming.
Here are samples that show vignetting and corner sharpness:
Mandler at ƒ/11Center sharpness is extremely high even at ƒ/2Bottom and all corner sharpness at ƒ/2 is lowBottom and all corner sharpness at ƒ/11 is highCenter is sharp at all aperturesSharp center, softer mids and starts to sharpen towards the very far edges only seen in flat walls until ƒ8 .
Technical Specs at a Glance for this Mandler
Feature
Specification
Optical Design
7 Elements in 5 Groups (v4 Homage)
Aperture Blades
10
Min. Focus Distance
0.7m
Filter Thread
39mm
Weight
~139g (Aluminum) / ~250g+ (Brass)
Price
~$348 – $538 USD (lens only)
Vignetting:
In my test, the visual vignetting in an exposed sky starts to dissolve at an aperture of f/5.6 but seems to stay through all of the aperture values. For me this is a positive character, when using an artistic lens makes much more sense as it adds to the feel of an image. Below is ƒ/5.6 and ƒ/2
Should You Buy It?
We aren’t halfway through this review and I will say it easily… Yes, it is only $348 for the ultra lightweight Aluminum black version. While this lens isn’t going to replace the original v4 nor any other new design it is still a really fun lens to start or to spice your photography style which could include the streets, travel spots or environmental portraits. If you find modern lenses too “sterile,” the Mandler 35mm ƒ/2 is a revelation. It provides its own spice plus the flavor of the King of Bokeh for 20% of the price. It is much better deal than any lens at this price point with this vintage character. Review continues below:
Comes in its own jewel box!
There are two hoods and I cannot decide which looks cooler, one day use one and swap it on your next exit.
The hoods are compatible with the original Leica lens but can also mount on other A39 lenses as I have mounted them on my Leica Summicron 35mm 8E.
Sharp center, vintage mids and soft edges. A classic!
The feels, that’s how they get me:
This Mandler 35mm is a lens that focuses on the feeling of a photo rather than the MTF chart. It was about two or three years ago that I started to see that in my personal search for ultimate sharpness… I looked away from organic feel and the Mandler 35mm is a refreshing reminder that sometimes, the most beautiful images are the ones with a little bit of “soul” in the glass.
Super sharp center and soft mids towards edge af ƒ/2
Comparing the Mandler 35mm ƒ/2, the Light Lens Lab (LLL) 8-Element, and the Leica Summicron 35mm v4 (the “King of Bokeh”) is a fascinating look at how modern manufacturers are recreating legendary optics. You cannot ever get the original taste in a copy but that’s why emulators are fun and for $350 this is a really fun lens to play or even start a rangefinder kit with a low budget.
Mandler 7E (left) and original Leitz Summicron 8E (right)
While all three are compact ƒ/2 lenses for the Leica M-mount, they represent two different eras of optical design. The Mandler and Leica v4 are 7-element designs (late 70s-90s), while the LLL is an 8-element design (late 50s-60s).
If you are a landscape photographer who needs edge-to-edge perfection at ƒ/2, look elsewhere. You’ll be much happier with a modern Leica/Voigtlander or any APO.
Quick Spec Comparison of these popular 35mm lenses
Feature
Mandler 35mm f/2
LLL 8-Element v1
Leica Summicron v4
Optical Formula
7 Elements / 5 Groups
8 Elements / 6 Groups
7 Elements / 5 Groups
Era Emulated
Late Mandler era (v4)
Early Mandler era (v1)
Original “King of Bokeh”
Build Material (Options)
Chromed Brass or Aluminum
Chromed, Black Paint, Titanium, Dense Solid Brass
Aluminum / Plastic
Focus Tab
Yes (Classic Plastic Leica style)
Yes (Metal with Infinity Lock)
Yes (Plastic concave)
Price (approx.)
$350 – $540
$1,000 – $1,200
$2,500 – $3,500+
Corner features are smudgedly vintage
Optical Character & Rendering
The biggest difference lies in which “flavor” of vintage you prefer.
The Mandler 35mm f/2 (The v4 Homage):
Rendering: This lens is a modern attempt to clone the v4’s soul. It has a very sharp center, even wide open, but the edges are intentionally soft and “glowy” at ƒ/2.
Bokeh: It captures the “painterly” fall-off of the v4. However, note that it has a slightly wider field of view (closer to 33mm or 34mm) compared to the original.
The “Glow”: It exhibits aberrations wide open, which creates a romantic mistiness around highlights.
Light Lens Lab 8-Element (The Summicron 35mm v1 Replica):
Rendering: Based on the earliest 35mm Summicron, it offers a “cinematic” look. It has lower contrast than the Mandler or the v4, giving it a more “filmic” or flat profile that handles highlights beautifully. I love this lens and I own an original v1 plus a LLL 8E.
Character: It is famous for its “glow” (lower contrast wide open) and a very gentle roll-off into the corners. It is the most “antique” feeling of the three.
Distortion: Virtually zero. It is one of the most distortion-free 35mm lenses ever made.
Leica Summicron v4 (The Original “KOB”):
Rendering: The gold standard for many. It is known for ƒ/2 performance that is sharp enough in the center for portraits but features a background blur that is unique.
The “King” Title: Interestingly, it earned its “King of Bokeh” name not for its performance wide open (where it can be busy), but for how the bokeh smooths out into a creamy masterpiece at ƒ/5.6 and here you thought it was because of ƒ/2
Sunstar character
Glowy and artsy at ƒ/2
Good and technical at ƒ/5.6
Mike Johnston: Years ago, rather unfortunately in some ways, I named the 35mm Summicron-M v.4 as the “King of Bokeh”. … The epithet has taken on a life of its own since then…especially when that lens is for sale somewhere. … I was missing part of the story at the time (1997). You see I never shot the lens wide open and very seldomly as little as one stop down. It does have wonderfully coherent blur—from ƒ/5.6 and moderate distances. That brilliant but flawed lens doesn’t look its best (in any respect) wide open, or close up.’
Build Quality and Handling
Mandler: Surprisingly high quality for the price. The brass version feels dense and premium. It mimics the ergonomics of the v4 perfectly, including the 39mm filter thread and the classic focusing tab. I prefer the aperture control of this lens, it is easier to turn with one finger.
Light Lens Lab: Often cited as having the same build quality as the Leica original. It is incredibly heavy for its size (all brass) and the tolerances are extremely tight. It includes a functional infinity lock, which the other two lack. The aperture ring requires a two finger touch to turn.
Leica v4: Known as the “Pre-ASPH” era, the build is actually its weak point in those that use a plastic aperture ring and some internal plastic components. Over decades, these can feel “loose” or develop play. It is, however, the lightest of the group, which many street photographers prefer. I’ve never been fond to this aluminium/plastic version.
Really sharp in center and artsy towards the corners
The aperture clicks on this Mandler are distinct from other lenses I’ve used, though perhaps a bit “clickier but softer” than the dampened feel of a V1 Summicron 35mm 8E. The focus throw is smooth and it includes a focusing tab, which is non-negotiable for anyone who shoots from the hip.
Flare Resistance and Coatings
Mandler: Uses modern multi-coatings. It actually resists flare better than a standard vintage v4 but retains some “ghosting” artifacts that enthusiasts find charming.
LLL: Specifically uses coatings designed to match the 1950s look. It can flare significantly more than the Mandler when shooting into the sun, producing beautiful, classic rainbow or veil flares.
Leica v4: Most copies have older single or early multi-coatings. It is prone to veiling glare if the light is hitting it from the side and more when there is internal haze.
Mandler 35mm at ƒ/2LLL 35mm 8E at ƒ/2
Summary Recommendation
Choose the Mandler 35mm ƒ/2 if you want the “King of Bokeh” look and experience on a budget. It provides so much of the v4 experience for 20% of the price and to me the brass version feels better. Very sharp center and soft corners.
Choose the Light Lens Lab 8-Element if you want the ultimate “heritage” feel. It’s for the photographer who loves the low-contrast, 1960s Leica glow and wants a lens built like a tank. Good sharpness and good corners.
Choose the Leica Summicron v1 8-Element if you want the real heritage everytihng and can cost anywhere from $3000 to $7000.
Choose the Leica Summicron v4 if you are a collector or want the genuine, lightweight “KOB” that will likely hold or increase its value over time, but I also recommend the brass version that costs around $6500.
Side by side comparison
I also compared these lenses in a controlled environment, any color variation is because the glass of each lens. These were focused on the Steiff label:
Zeiss Distagon 35mm ƒ/1.4
Leica Summaron 35mm ƒ/3.5
LLL 8E (Summicron v1) ƒ/2
Mandler (Summicron v4) ƒ/2
100% crop Mandler at ƒ/2100% crop LLL 8E at ƒ/2100% crop Zeiss Distagon at ƒ/2
Below, the Mandler lens is very sharp in center. These were focused on the left eye:
Mandler ƒ/2LLL 8E ƒ/2Zeiss Distagon ƒ/2Summaron ƒ/3.5
Background blur character. Focused on left eye in Leica bear as above:
MandlerLLL 8EZeiss Distagon
Here is a very important visual reference that everyone should know, as you move away from the center of focus, the Mandler has a very vintage rendering or what I think is field curvature, notice the engravings on the lens that seems to show motion blur but it isn’t. Pay attention to these 3 samples also focused on the left eye of the Leica bear:
MandlerLLL 8EZeiss Distagon
The Zeiss Distagon being the best, it sits just below the APO lenses for its very well optical performance.
Earlier I showed you a portrait in black and white, the side of his beard is very sharp and that was the Mandler lens. At this point I am not sure what distances suffer from that field curvature because it is not noticeable in that portrait, instead everything in his face looks very very sharp. This Mandler is very interesting and requires more testing.
Mandler corner performance is low at ƒ/2LLL 8E corner performance is good at ƒ/2Mandler: Very sharp center, soft mids and softer corners.Summicron v1 8E: Soft glow, good sharpness across the entire field at f/2 and very sharp across the field at f/4 and shows nervous background blur (I call it vintage)